Averaging and forecasting answer the same broad question in different ways: how much employment tax should have been deducted by this point, given what is known about the year?
Averaging uses the earnings pattern so far to annualise the position. Forecasting combines earnings already received with an estimate of the regular earnings still expected. The difference becomes particularly visible when an employee receives a payment that is not expected to repeat.
Both sit within FDS. They should not be confused with the separate decision about whether an employee belongs under FDS or Non-FDS. ZIMRA’s employee-management FAQ says the employer may choose averaging or forecasting, but cannot switch between them within the same tax year. [S08]
Begin with the same employee and the same facts
Consider a fictional employee paid USD1,000 in January and USD1,000 in February. In March, the employee receives the usual USD1,000 plus USD600 of once-off taxable overtime. The employee is assumed to be correctly classified under FDS, employed for the full year, with no credits or other adjustments.
At the end of March, taxable earnings to date are USD3,600. Regular earnings expected for each of April to December are USD1,000. The USD600 is not expected to recur.
Those facts are identical under both methods. What changes is the treatment of the remaining year.
The calculation mechanics below follow ZIMRA’s historical FDS guide. The guide is used for the method, not its old monetary thresholds or administrative procedures. [S09]
Averaging annualises the pattern so far
The average monthly taxable earnings after March are USD3,600 divided by three: USD1,200. Annualising that average gives USD14,400.
In the simplified no-credit illustration, the method calculates annual tax on that annualised amount, takes the proportion attributable to the three elapsed months, and subtracts tax already deducted. As more months pass without the once-off overtime recurring, the average changes.
This does not mean the employer has decided that another USD600 will be paid every month. It means that the annualised estimate reflects the earnings pattern observed so far. That distinction helps explain why a temporary spike can affect current withholding more strongly under averaging.
A reviewer should be able to see the year-to-date earnings, elapsed periods, annualised amount and prior deductions. Without those components, the result can look like an unexplained change in the employee’s tax rate.
Forecasting estimates the remaining regular earnings
For the same employee, forecasting begins with USD3,600 already earned and adds nine future months at USD1,000. The resulting projected annual taxable earnings are USD12,600.
The once-off overtime remains part of the annual taxable total. It is not ignored. It is simply not projected as a recurring future payment.
In this simplified example, the projected annual tax less prior deductions is spread over the remaining deduction periods, including the current one. At the March calculation, there are ten such periods: March through December. [S09]
The quality of that estimate depends on the recurring-pay assumptions. A permanent salary increase and a once-off payment should not be treated as though they tell the same story about future earnings.
A numerical comparison using the 2025 table
For illustration only, apply ZIMRA’s published 2025 USD annual table and its 3% AIDS levy. This is a historical calculation, not a statement of the table applicable to a live November 2026 payroll. [S05]
At USD12,000 annual taxable income, tax before the levy is USD2,580. Including the levy gives USD2,657.40, or USD221.45 for each of the first two months under the simplified assumptions. Prior deductions at the start of the March calculation therefore total USD442.90.
| March comparison | Averaging | Forecasting |
|---|---|---|
| Taxable earnings already received | USD3,600.00 | USD3,600.00 |
| Annualised or projected taxable earnings | USD14,400.00 | USD12,600.00 |
| Annual tax before AIDS levy | USD3,300.00 | USD2,760.00 |
| Annual tax including AIDS levy | USD3,399.00 | USD2,842.80 |
| Prior deductions | USD442.90 | USD442.90 |
| Illustrative March deduction | USD406.85 | USD239.99 |
For averaging, the working is USD3,399 × 3/12, less USD442.90. For forecasting, it is (USD2,842.80 − USD442.90) divided by ten.
The different March deductions do not mean the two methods impose different annual tax rates. They produce different timing profiles because they estimate the annual position differently during the year.
What happens if the remaining months follow the forecast?
If the employee receives USD1,000 in each remaining month, actual annual taxable earnings finish at USD12,600. Under consistent assumptions, the final annual liability is based on that completed year, not on the higher annualised estimate temporarily produced in March.
The final reconciliation should bring cumulative deductions into line with the applicable annual liability, allowing for the method, permitted adjustments and rounding. ZIMRA’s FAQ states that the methods should produce the same result at year-end. [S08]
In practice, a changed salary, further irregular earnings, credits where permitted or a change in employment circumstances can complicate the picture. This illustration deliberately excludes those issues so that the difference between the methods remains visible.
The classification of pay items matters
A forecast needs a defensible distinction between recurring and irregular amounts. Basic salary may be expected to continue. Overtime, a commission or leave-related payment might be regular in one arrangement and genuinely once-off in another. The label alone should not make the decision.
Record the expected treatment and review it when the employment arrangement changes. Do not retrospectively describe an unexpected payment as predictable simply to justify a result.
For averaging, review the completeness of the cumulative history. Missing earlier earnings or tax deductions can distort the current calculation even when this month’s input is correct.
What to ask when the figures differ
Check that both calculations use the same employee facts, tax year, taxable components, table, credit assumptions and prior deductions. Then inspect the annualised or forecast amount and the period count.
Only after those comparisons should the reviewer conclude that a difference is unexplained. Comparing final deductions without comparing assumptions can make two internally coherent calculations appear contradictory.
Neither method removes the need for judgement. The practical standard is that the chosen method is permitted, consistently applied and supported by records that explain both the current deduction and the year-end position.
References
- S05 · ZIMRA — Foreign currency PAYE tax tables, January–December 2025. 2025 tax year.
- S08 · ZIMRA — PAYE return: Employee Management Module FAQs. 2025 guidance.
- S09 · ZIMRA; copy hosted by Touchstone — Final Deduction System guide, 2014. 2014.